The potential benefits of Human Resource Outsourcing (HRO), have been well documented but not always delivered. These include reducing cost, avoiding HR technology investment, re-aligning HR towards delivering more strategy and improving HR services. (see Top 5 Benefits of HR Outsourcing). Choosing a vendor that matches your requirements and will work with your culture is difficult enough, but it also important to take a view on who the likely ‘winners’ will be in the HRO industry.

At the moment, in supporting our clients as they look at their HR Transformation options, we think one of the biggest challenges is that of ‘picking winners’. Whether considering HR Outsourcing for the first time, re-energising an existing contract or simply bringing the whole show back in-house. A wrong decision now could mean you are lumbered with the wrong vendor, solution or the wrong technology platform for the next 7-10 years. This has always been a challenge, yet is more significant now with big changes in the HRO industry. Nothing distracts the vendor’s senior management team more than mergers, acquisitions and a major change in direction.

Lessons have been learnt since the first generation HRO contracts of ten years ago, such as BP/Exult (for an interesting account, see The Great Vendor Bender free login required to HRO Today website) which has renewed its contract with Hewitt, following an ‘about-turn’ of its plans. As David Ulrich, a professor at the University of Michigan’s Ross School of Business reflected, ‘Often the first pancakes or first batch of cookies do not come out well.’

The giant HRO deal between Accenture and Unilever in 2006 has now been ‘digested’ following some implementation challenges. Since then, the HRO market has fragmented with some big players moving back to their ‘comfort zone’, focusing on their core markets and strengths, for example, Hewitt.

Other major changes in the industry include acquisitions such as ACS/Xerox, more ‘best-in-breed’ deals and the rapid rise of Recruitment Process Outsourcing (RPO), see for example, RPO ends 2009 with a big bang and begins 2010 on a high note. Buyers are now more likely to have a HR Operating Model with multiple HR vendors covering areas such as HRIS, Payroll and RPO. In fact increasingly more and more is up for grabs in HR outsourcing, see the People Management Guide to Outsourcing – Out of the Ordinary, including our thoughts on what should be outsourced and what should be retained.

As we predicted in our attempt to peer into the future of HR in our ‘Glass Bead Crystal Ball’, Future of HR Operating Models, there is still more consolidation to come in this $6 Billion Global industry. For more info, see HRO provider acquisitions on the rise from HR Outsourcing insights blog.

Hot off the press, Northgate Arinso have acquired the HR Management Services of Convergys. This is a bold bet on the future of the HRO market, and should combine the HR Service Delivery capability of Convergys US and European HR Service Centers, with Northgate Arinsos innovation and technical strengths. See Horses for Sources, the new Analyst firm in the starting stalls, with their take on the deal NorthgateArinso buys its way to top spot in Enterprise HRO and it only cost them $100m.

In picking a vendor, ‘financial stability’ has always been important in our Glass Bead Consulting weighted evaluation criteria, but now this has a much higher rating than 4 or 5 years ago. The rare AAA credit rating of ADP has a bigger pull than ever before.

Many organisations are attracted to the ‘on-demand’ HR outsourcing model with a view that there is no need to host the technology yourself with employees accessing services over the internet. This reduces some of the risks of picking the right technology platform, as it’s taken out of your hands. See for example, Northgate Arinsos 7 year HRO contract with Astra Zeneca, in 105 countries and 65,000 employees, based on their ‘euHReka platform’.

So the HRO market is changing all the time and the benefits and risks of HR Outsourcing will vary for each organisation, its requirements and context.

To minimise your risks in choosing a HRO vendor, consider the following :-

1. Think carefully about your Sourcing Strategy, will you put all your eggs in one basket or go for a best-of-breed approach with HR Processes? Make sure that the different vendors will be able to work with each other culturally and operate with compatible technology.
2. Establish your vendor evaluation criteria up front, work out as an organisation what are the relative weightings and identify any ‘deal-breakers’.
3. Work with your legal team to develop flexibility into the contract, including break-clauses and allowing interfaces with other vendors.
4. Consider using an independent HR outsourcing advisor who will know the market well and take you straight through to the Request for Proposal short-listing based on your requirements.
5. In your vendor evaluation, listen carefully to the vendor’s answers on their long-term strategy for HR Outsourcing.

Finally, there are great benefits for HRO as part of a broader strategy of transforming HR or to reduce costs, but keep an eye on the marketplace and picking a winner will pay a healthy return.

There are more useful HR Outsourcing resources in the HR Transformation Knowledge Bank

Photo Credit :- Andy Spence – Brighton Races – October 2004

Are UK HR professionals the ’social butterflies’ of the online World? Researchers monitored 2000 online conversations in the UK over September and October as part of their research. The conversations included employers, consultancies, and employees discussing HR related topics. The interesting report from CHA, the workplace communications consultancy, was based on research by online specialist Pass It On Media. It found that the tone of conversations was mainly neutral to positive which surprised the researchers who expected more ‘angst’ in the current economic environment. The report is worth a read with innovative research, case-studies from Virgin, E.ON UK and Dell, and some very useful and practical tips for employees and employers alike. Download the PDF "Conversations at your fingertips – How HR professionals score as social networkers"

The findings that stand out for me :-

1. 1. The key venues for conversation are message boards or forums, which account for 54%, followed by social networks such as LinkedIn (23%) and blogs (23%).
2. 2. Broadly, the themes covered are: the working environment & friendship at work, salaries & related issues, how people are feeling, and work/life balance & holidays.
3. 3. The top five are LinkedIn, Facebook, iVillage, Netmums and UK Business Labs.
4. 4. Busiest day for social networking about employment issues are Thursdays and Fridays.
5. 5. Social Networks are now more popular than personal emails.
6. 6. The term ‘human resources’ has been used only 13,000 times on Twitter "HR" has been used a staggering 323,000 times in the life of Twitter.

For trends in UK Social Media usage, the map below comes from Are you LinkedIn in London or Bebo in Belfast? and show the regionalisation of various social networks, as of September 2009. With Facebook and Twitter’s growth leveling off, and Bebo and MySpace continuing to lose audience it will be very interesting to run these again in 2010.

Possible questions for further research is how do other functions compare to HR and what are the trends in other countries?

This is a summary of an original article published by Strategic HR Review.

In an economic downturn and subsequent recovery, change is inevitable for every organization. Effective Change Management is often a mix of the strategic and the practical. It can encompass everything from ensuring strategies are aligned, to making sure your weekly bulletin goes out on time, on message and to the right people. From a HR perspective, it is important to provide leadership and guidance by example and the following actions can help HR executives to lead the way during the change process.

1. Define and deliver your HR strategy

Make sure that HR strategy is consistent with the overall business strategy, and where necessary provide input and ideas into the overall business strategy. Make sure you achieve buy-in from key stakeholders. This can be achieved by clearly outlining your proposed improvements and delivering on project ideas early on. Part of aligning HR strategy with the overall business strategy will be achieved by sharpening your HR operating model and asking how each HR role will support your organization in the next 12 months. You will be better able to respond quickly to organizational changes with better HR systems, more effective processes and better aligned capabilities in place. This allows HR to deal with the next new change more effectively.

2. Understand HR cost drivers

It is vital to know what drives HR costs. If you know your key performance metrics and what has an effect on them, you can quickly demonstrate that you understand the cost, service and risk implications of any proposed organizational changes on your own department. A good grasp of the cost implications of strategic decisions and the analysis to back it up – really helps when it comes to making changes. By conducting an assessment of the HR department, you get a better understanding of your internal benchmarks. A key metric for HR to understand is the HR “Cost to Serve”of each employee, including staff, systems and third parties. This can vary widely between businesses and geographies and it is important to know why.

3. Take a lead on sourcing options

Take the outsourcing decision to your board – do not let the board take it to you. Be proactive and do the research into how outsourcing could benefit your department (see article Top 5 Benefits of HR Outsourcing)and bring about positive change, as well as cost-savings. Show that you have been actively looking at alternative ways to provide better and more cost-effective HR services in payroll, IT, recruitment, training, HR administration and benefits. Develop your own “build or buy” criteria to help gradually improve HR services. Demonstrate that your business case takes into account the benefits of moving from fixed cost to a more variable cost (that will help in the downturn and the subsequent upturn).

4. Lead by example

There is a balancing act that good HR directors need to master. Often, HR directors are so outwardly focused on supporting the organization that they can neglect the day-to-day workings of their own department. When aligning HR strategy to the wider business strategy, HR directors need to focus on the internal working of the HR department, and most importantly, the people within the HR department. Show leadership through developing your talented team members, and use this as your core team to lead change. Retention strategies start at home, so show the board what you are doing to keep and develop your most talented team members. Be innovative. The organization will look to the HR department to lead on this – secondments, project roles and recognizing excellent service are all initiatives that can inspire people within the organization.

5. Implement change decisively and calmly

All executives in the organization must demonstrate leadership by managing change in a calm and decisive way. HR can stop the organization making “knee-jerk” reactions – more than ever, this is the time to make the right decisions for your organization. Implement changes calmly, effectively and consistently.

Glass Bead Consulting announce ‘HR Transformation Workshop’
Institute of Directors, London – March 5th 2009

Glass Bead Consulting have announced an advanced HR Transformation workshop designed to give HR Executives a headstart in transforming the HR function. The one day course will be held at the Institute of Directors, Pall Mall, London.
Click here for more details about the course and how to book.

Glass Bead Consulting announce ‘HR Outsourcing Workshop’
Institute of Directors, London – March 31st 2009

Glass Bead Consulting have announced an HR Outsourcing Workshop ‘Delivering the benefits and managing the risks’ – a workshop designed to give an overview of what HR outsourcing can do for your organisation. The one day course will be held at the Institute of Directors, Pall Mall, London.
Click here for more details about the course and how to book.

Technorati Profile

Glass Bead Consulting, a new consultancy firm which advises on HR Transformation and HR Outsourcing, today announces its launch across Europe. Glass Bead Consulting aims to help organisations transform the way HR is delivered by changing ‘what’ and ‘how’ HR is delivered.

Andrew Spence, Glass Bead Consulting’s founder and Managing Director, comments:
“There is a gap in the market when it comes to specialist HR management consultancies. If HR is to really cement its place on the board, it needs to become much more strategic in outlook, and to effect real change. Our experienced consultants offer a thorough assessment of your HR department identifying areas for ‘quick wins’ as well as long-term transformation options.”

Glass Bead Consulting typically works with clients at different stages in the HR Transformation lifecycle, including assessment, vision, planning and implementation, as well as advising on making the business case for change, managing change and project management. The consultancy works in genuine partnership with clients, providing tools and templates, as well as offering training.

Andrew Spence continues:
“We can help you to work out what HR needs to do, to organise your HR department effectively and to help develop your HR service delivery options. Our approach is based on our unique offerings including the HR Transformation Health Check™ and advanced workshops. We train your team to use these tools effectively as well as sharing our skills to ensure long term success.”

Glass Bead consultants have delivered HR transformation goals across different sectors and geographies and using different tactics, having worked from the vantage point of HR outsourcing, HR delivery and HR consultancy.

For more information contact:
Andrew Spence
Glass Bead Consulting
Managing Director
+44 (0)1273 888 182
info@glassbeadconsulting.com

PR Contact:
Laura Munns
+44 (0)20 7392 2632
+44 (0)7827 995 180
laura@rostrumpr.com

The HR Transformer Blog is a human resources blog that aims to provide useful information, industry commentary and consulting tools for anyone with an interest in transforming Human Resources.

The blog is mostly written by Andy Spence, founder of Glass Bead Consulting and an experienced management consultant.

By HR Transformation we mean specific HR projects that attempt to align people, processes and technology more closely with an organisations business strategy and vision.

This is a rapidly changing field at the intersection of technology, strategy and large demographic and economic change.

The blog will cover tried and tested techniques including Project Management, Change Management, HR Outsourcing, Organisation Design and HR Information Systems as well as emerging themes in delivering HR Strategy.

We look forward to the conversations.